How to tell if a wine is corked?





What does it mean for a wine to be corked and how can one tell when it is? CellarVie Wines spoke exclusively to Dorian Guillon, the Assistant Head Sommelier at Alain Ducasse at The Dorchester, to find out the tell-tale signs of corked wine and what the industry is doing to combat this age old problem. Dorian recently won the Court of Master Sommeliers Advanced Sommelier Riedel Trophy. The Riedel Trophy is awarded to the candidate that scores the highest aggregate mark of all the examinations held in the calendar year.  
 
How does a wine become corked?

A cork taint is a reaction between a penicillium mould in the tiny fissure of the cork and the chlorine chemical used during the sterilising process. This reaction produces TCA (2,4,6-Trichloroanisole), a substance with a strong fungal aroma.
 
 
What are the tell-tale signs a wine is corked?

The most important sign to recognise a corked wine is the smell: it will smell musty and mouldy and will have little fruit aromas left.
 

Can a wine be fine on the nose but taste decidedly ‘corked’?

As there are different levels of TCA sometimes it is harder to point out the cork taint just by smelling it. If you have no fruit and very little flavour, I recommend you have a taste and swirl the wine around your mouth, as with oxygen the TCA will become more perceptible. Remember that you don't need to swallow - even though corked wine is not bad for you, it is not necessary to torture yourself - just spit it out!
 

If there are bits of cork floating in the wine is the wine "corked"?

A wine containing small pieces of cork as a result of a crumbly cork is not corked, neither faulty. The cork was probably too old or very dry. You can simply remove the pieces of cork and keep drinking your wine.
 

Is corked wine the result of a contaminated cork or can this occur in the barrel or other cooperage elements during the winemaking process?

Most of the time, corked wine is the result of a contaminated cork. Every time I have found a corked wine, the cork smelt of TCA as well, and not just the wine. This is why Sommeliers smell corks when opening a bottle of wine.

But TCA can be transmitted to wine stored in bulk in wineries from many sources other than corks, particularly from wood used in the construction of wineries and tainted shipping pallets. This explains why traces of TCA can also be found in wines bottled with screw-caps.
 
 
Can only cheap wines get corked?

There used to be a relation between cheap wines and corked bottles, when large producers were cutting costs by using corks of a lower grade and shorter length. The consequence was the development of alternative closures, although having said that very expensive bottles of wines can still be corked. But don't worry, if you go in a restaurant and order an expensive bottle of wine, Sommeliers are trained to smell corked wine and will change the bottle before it even gets to your table.
 
 
Dorian Guillon [centre] with The Court of Master Sommeliers Advanced Sommelier Riedel Trophy 
 
Is there a noticeable difference in colour if a wine is corked?

No.
 

Can you send back a corked wine?

Absolutely. If you purchase your wine in a retailer, take back the bottle and most will be helpful and will agree to exchange it.
 
 
Can a screw cap wine be ‘corked’?

It is one of the many advantages of screw caps, as they do not cause cork taint.
 

Is cork taint decreasing and how is the industry trying to limit the number of corked bottles?

Corked wine only represents approximately 2-3% of all wines. The industry has already found alternative to natural corks for cheaper wines with a short shelf-life, such as agglomerated and colmated corks.

For the more expensive wines, scientist are busy looking for solutions to eliminate TCA from natural corks, without success yet. The special cork Diam seems to offer a solution; it uses super-critical Carbon Dioxide to remove TCA. It is an alternative that is nonetheless more expensive than natural cork, but seems to guarantee no cork taint. I remember Hugel et Fils telling me that since they began using the Diam corks, they had no corked taint on any bottles. Research is still ongoing to see if this system can be used for natural corks.
 


 
For reservations at Alain Ducasse at the Dorchester
Call: +44 (0)20 7629 8866
or email: alainducassereservations@alainducasse-dorchester.com
 


 
 
 
 
 

Written by: Ben Moss

Ben Moss 

16.09.15

BBQ Spatchcock Piri-Piri Chicken


Summer has come to a close and autumn is well and truly on its way. Blustering winds, cooler temperatures and swiftly shortening days mean it will soon be time to wrap up warm and to make the most of the wonderful autumn produce on offer. Time to say goodbye to those fresh, summer whites and replace them with the warmer, more robust reds frequently associated with colder temperatures.
26.08.15

What to drink with Fish Pie?


Fish Pie is a quintessentially British recipe. Easy to make and absolutely delicious, it is also a great dinner party dish - with a limited amount of last minute preparations needed it’s a winner in my book! However, where do you start when matching a fish pie with wine?
24.07.15

Five Ways to Open a Bottle of Wine Without a Corkscrew


For that moment when you find yourself without a corkscrew and unable to open that bottle of wine; here are five ways to open a bottle of wine without a corkscrew. Obviously, if you do have a corkscrew to hand, it is a lot easier to go down the more traditional route…



19.05.15

World’s first cork with no carbon footprint

The perpetual ‘cork versus screw-top’ debate just got more complicated as the world’s first carbon neutral cork is introduced. read more


13.05.15

Top Ten Most Ridiculous Wine Accessories

We will let you decide whether or not these ten ridiculous accessories add use, versatility or attractiveness to wine… read more


12.05.15

Top Five Most Over the Top Tasting Notes

Surely there is no one who's worked for any period of time in the wine trade who hasn't drifted, at one time or another, into the realms of the mildly absurd when it comes to describing a wine. I can remember fairly early in my career ... read more


23.04.15

Ten Things to Know About Sauvignon Blanc

It is Sauvignon Blanc Day this Friday the 24th April and so here are ten things you to know about this wonderfully diverse and iconic grape variety. Now the weather has blossomed (thankfully) and the temperatures are ... read more


21.04.15

What I've Learned…Vincent Pastorello

Head of Wines at The Dorchester, overseeing the wine list at Alain Ducasse at The Dorchester, Vincent Pastorello discusses working with one of the world's most revered chefs, his schooling under Gordon Ramsey and the key to wine and food ... read more


13.04.15

Cheese & Wine Matching Guide with Susie Barrie MW & Peter Richards MW

CellarVie Wines tracked down the youngest married Masters of Wine in the business, Peter Richards and Susie Barrie, in order to get their expert opinion on the perfect wine and cheese pairings. The dynamic duo are stalwarts of BBC1's ... read more


20.03.15

The Best Wine Pairings for Lamb: CellarVie vs The Experts

A dish as wonderfully tender as lamb is hugely popular in spring and a common choice for a Sunday lunch, especially over the long Easter weekend. One of the most flexible of meats when it comes to wine pairing, it is normally the ... read more


19.02.15

What wine to drink with Roast Chicken?

With roast beef and roast lamb chalked off the list, we wanted to bring you the perfect wine pairings with that other Great British Sunday lunch staple; roast chicken. As ever, we have sought out the wisdom of a few carefully selected ... read more


29.01.15

Ten Great Wine Bars in London

With the alarmingly large array of watering holes in our beautiful capital, we have taken it upon ourselves to hunt down some of the best wine bars (a tricky job, I can tell you) in London, so you can try them out for yourselves. ... read more


26.01.15

The perfect wine pairings with Moroccan Spiced Lamb

An indulgence apt for Easter, but one that’s so good we’d urge you to give this a go beforehand… With lambing season imminent, this seasonal recipe for Moroccan spiced rack of lamb is just what’s needed to jazz up the wet, wintery ... read more


23.01.15

What wine to drink with Roast Beef?

The cathartic powers of Sunday Lunch is something the British embrace more than most and having recently brought you the perfect wine pairings for roast lamb, courtesy of a few carefully chosen expert suggestions, we wanted to do ... read more


13.01.15

What wine to drink with Roast Lamb?

Sunday lunch is a rite of passage for the English. It is a meal and an occasion that we can collectively claim to have nailed; a restorative window amid our busy week set aside for communal revelry in family, friendship and food. The ... read more


07.01.15

Debunking Myths about Riesling with…Stuart Pigott

Increasingly prominent on wine lists and shop shelves, Riesling is also perhaps the most beloved varietal within the trade; by winemakers, sommeliers and critics alike; the legendary Jancis Robison cites Riesling as "indisputably the ... read more


02.12.14

What I’ve Learned…Oz Clarke

One third of the Three Wine Men with Olly Smith and Tim Atkin, the wine expert, author and charismatic television presenter, Oz Clarke, reflects on his enduring love of Bordeaux, the influence of the New World and what it was like to be ... read more



Post a comment...